patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices
The Arts, gardening, education, good food & drink.

'Legitimate Rape' Todd Akin Comment Rekindles Trail of Tears Pain

Representative Todd Akin's "legitimate rape" comment on Sunday drew a firestorm of reaction, as well it should. Rape is never "legitimate" and it is always a crime of violence. The concept takes this blogger back about 175 years to a bit of forgotten Missouri history: the Trail of Tears.

The Cherokee Nation became a victime when gold was discovered in northern Georgia in the 1830's. A minority of Cherokee signed a treaty with the U.S. government (led by President Andrew Jackson). Over the next two years (1838 and 1839), approximately 15,000 Cherokee were re-settled in the Oklahoma Territory. This forced march, also described as genocide, covered three routes from Georgia westward, including one through southern Missouri and Cape Gireardeau. Along the way, approximately 4,000 Cherokee died of exposure, hunger, and disease. Literally hundreds of Cherokee women were raped, abducted, and forced to marry or serve as wives to settlers along the way.

Hence the tie-in to Representative Akin's remark. The U.S. government "legitimately" stole the land of the Cherokee, a sovereign people. The resulting "forced march" resulted in the literal rape of their nation and its women.

The state of Missouri commemorates this travesty with the Trail of Tears State Park. Congressman Akin with his poor word choice rocks our present with his ignorance. Remember his words and our ancestors' shameful participation in the Trail of Tears as you make your way to the polls this November.

Pat Wilken Maloney

11:54 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

SPOT ON, Mr. Cockson....I said the same thing, there is no such thing as "legitimate" rape. I can't understand him saying that. I have had at least two Facebook friends who have said they voted for him in the Primary Election, and regret doing so now. I think he has "cooked his own goose" this weekend, and don't believe he will win that election in Nov.

Reply

Mark Cockson

4:01 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Liz Goodwin of Yahoo! News is reporting that, as of two hours ago, Rep. Akin may drop out of the Senate race; he has until Tuesday to do so for the Republicans to nominate someone else to run against Senator Claire McCaskill, otherwise it will take a court order....Blogger Mark

Reply

Gina Veesaert

6:06 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

You think McCaskill will beat him because of this one bumbling word choice, after how many years? Even those of us women who don't want to vote for him and are irritated with his idiocy won't let that happen.

Reply

Mark Cockson

6:03 am on Tuesday, August 21, 2012

Hello, Gina:
No, this was more than a "bumbling word choice" as his "embedded video" in my blog talks about the biological consequences he thinks happens. Nor am I necessarily "pro-McCaskill"---I would prefer that he step aside so Republicans can choose someone better informed....Blogger Mark

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bryan Simmons

7:42 am on Thursday, August 23, 2012

I would prefer that he stay in. It's not like the entire GOP is any less hostile to women's reproductive rights. Akin just revealed their mindset. Akin and Paul Ryan were co-sponsors of language added to the Hyde Amendment prohibiting any Federal funds be used to terminate pregnancy for any reason, including "legitimate" rape, which they define as forcible rape that can be substantiated. The legislative history of that provision includes the junk science from one Dr. John Willke. http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2012/08/romney-endorsed-by-praised-dr-john-willke-leading-proponent-of-idea-that-rape-lowers-pregnancy-risk/261358/
--Bryan

Leave a comment